The New Judging Rules: Why Dressage Will Soon Score Feelings Instead of Movements
Forget rhythm, suppleness, and clean transitions—how the equestrian world’s mindfulness shift is replacing technical precision with emotional vulnerability.
For years, a strict, almost merciless principle ruled the dressage arena: execute a movement accurately, cleanly, and with pure rhythm, and you were rewarded with high marks. Make a mistake, and your score dropped. Yet in the wake of equestrianism’s grand mindfulness shift, this outdated performance mindset is finally being abolished. Under the new judging rules, the focus shifts to what truly matters in modern riding: not the technical quality of a movement, but the emotional state behind it.
From Cold Mechanics to Soul Connection
For the judges sitting around the arena, this requires a complete paradigm shift. A critical eye for rhythm errors, suppleness, and individual movements is largely a thing of the past. From now on, a technically flawless execution means very little if it isn't carried by inner warmth and a palpable soul connection.
Consequently, a pair might easily receive a sobering 6.0 for completely mistake-free one-tempi flying changes if the judges conclude that the strides, while geometrically precise, lacked emotional vulnerability. Simply checking boxes down the diagonal is, after all, nothing more than cold mechanics. Conversely, a 9.5 for a completely botched piaffe is now entirely plausible: if the horse decides to rein back instead of trotting on the spot, yet the rider signals through a soft, accepting facial expression that they are lovingly holding space for this process, the panel will reward that lived authenticity accordingly.
Celebrating Equine Boundaries
Horses with a strong will of their own will be especially prized. If a horse throws in a little buck after a messy transition, pins its ears, or steers autonomously toward the exit, this will no longer be penalized as resistance or disobedience. Instead, pairs will receive a generous bonus for horses that communicate their personal boundaries clearly and assertively. After all, no one in the arena should ever be forced beyond their current emotional capacity—even when the final piaffe is on the test sheet.
A Mindfulness Coach at C
To meet these demanding new evaluation standards, the judging panel itself is expanding. Sitting at C alongside the traditional dressage judge will be a certified mindfulness coach, who will skip noting technical faults altogether. Their sole job is to sense energetic blockages and award a holistic "well-being mark." Instead of dry remarks like "lacking frame extension" or "tilted at the poll," test sheets will finally feature contemporary feedback: "Wonderfully vulnerable in the extended trot. Still a bit too much in their head during the canter pirouette, but overall a deeply healing encounter."
Ribbons for Self-Acceptance, Not Percentages
The prize-giving ceremony is also getting an overhaul. Ranking riders by points and percentages is increasingly viewed as a toxic relic of old-school competitiveness. Instead, ribbons will be awarded for greatest emotional openness and most inspiring self-acceptance. Anyone who still manages to rack up the highest score is certainly allowed to be happy - provided they take care not to disrupt the energetic balance of the other competitors.
And should someone leave the ring with the lowest score of the day, there is no reason to feel discouraged. Under the new rules, there are no losers - only different stages of growth on the journey toward ultimate harmony. In the end, this not only saves tears, but also renders tedious weekday training largely obsolete.






Comments